In the tinker case, students wore black armbands to school in silent protest of the vietnam war. Foundations of education and instructional assessmentethics. Frederick, which asks if juneau schools wrongly quashed a student s freespeech rights. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus case nbc news. Jun 25, 2007 charles lane will have an article headlined court backs school on speech curbs. The court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus reasonably could be. The first section ends with ross analysis of morse, popularly known as the bong hits 4 jesus case. A conversation on the constitution with justices stephen. This moniker reflects the message on a banner held by high school senior joseph frederick at a quasischoolsponsored event in anchorage.
The supreme court tightened limits on student speech monday, ruling against a high school student and his 14footlong bong hits 4 jesus banner. Frederick, a student in alaska was suspended for holding up a banner at a schoolsponsored event that read bong hits 4 jesus. Joseph frederick was a senior on a mission when he set up his sign bong hits 4 jesus. The supreme court found that the principal hadnt violated the boys free speech rights, because it was part of the schools mission to protect students from messages that could be seen as. Oct 08, 2019 bong hits 4 jesus is one of the more entertaining one, and a good example of how all of this 1st amendment sanctimony goes out the window as soon as someone shouts can someone please think of. Oct 27, 2016 frederick in 2007 to say that a bong hits 4 jesus sign held by a high school student on sidewalk near campus, which administrators punished with a suspension, would have been protected if it. Many depict the school speech cases as fundamental alterations of studentschool relationships, or even of the basic role of minors in society. Frederick, the supreme court case that addressed free speech in an. Frederick, the majority acknowledged that the constitution affords lesser protections to certain types of student speech at school or at schoolsupervised events. Jun 25, 2007 it struck down limits on some campaign ads, restricted when taxpayers may sue over government aid to faith groups, and ruled against a teen and his bong hits for jesus banner. Justices will hear a case involving a student from alaska, who is. Juneaudouglas high school students had permission to go outside to watch the torch go by. It was certainly not intended as a drug or religious message. The bbc reports on the supreme court ruling that a school in alaska did not violate joseph fredericks right to free speech when it suspended him for displaying a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus.
A 5 4 majority cites perils of illegal drugs in case of the bong hits 4 jesus banner. Its taken 5 years but frederick took his case to the supreme court. Supreme court limits student speech in bong hits 4 jesus case, june 25, 2007. The us supreme court moved monday to tighten limits on free speech for high school students, ruling that an alaska high school could constitutionally punish a student who held up a 14footlong banner reading bong hits 4 jesus during a schoolrelated event. He gets his friends to help unfurl a homemade banner with the inscription bong hits 4 jesus. Thornton 1995 states cant set term limits on members of congress. It examines topics such as students access to judicial process. Can public school students constitutionally be punished for.
However in 2002, principal deborah morse violated the first amendment, when she tore down a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus. The supreme court held that a school could censor student speech that they believe. She justified her actions by citing the schools policy against the display of material that promotes the use of illegal drugs. And an article will report that justices quash suit over funds for faith groups. Bong hits 4 jesus as a cautionary tale of two cities. Biskupic was worded too vaguely and could include clothing. Speech the issue of freedom of speech has very often been misunderstood and misinterpreted by american citizens who believe they can say anything they want. Johnson 1989 said flag burning is symbolic speech and cannot be punished. Joseph frederick caused a stir by holding up a banner that read bong hits 4 jesus at an event attended by fellow juneaudouglas high school students. Washington cnn the supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. High court case tests limits of student speech rights. Frederick, otherwise known as the bong hits 4 jesus case, highlights the nonrealization of chief justice robertss goal of greater cohesion and unanimity. Making the fight over bong hits 4 jesus, a case that could define the limits on free speech for students.
In 2002, juneaudouglas high school principal deborah morse suspended joseph frederick. The student sued for free speech rights court ruled. Could bong hits 4 jesus case chill free speech in schools. Joseph fredericks unfurling of his bong hits 4 jesus. The supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits. In that opinion he called for removing first amendment protection for student speech and thus for overruling tinker v. Bong hits 4 jesus and the first amendment huffpost. Joseph frederick, a public school student, was suspended after he held up a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus at a televised. Student loses bong hits 4 jesus case june 25, 2007 10. Frederick, a high school student, displayed a banner at a local parade featuring the phrase bong hits 4 jesus, a reference to marijuana use. Frederick paralleled the rise of reality television and online selfexposure in the 2000s. When can schools limit students free speech rights. Bong hits 4 jesus banner on display at the newseum in washington, d.
Frederick said that the phrase bong hits 4 jesus was never meant to have any substantive meaning. Frederick paralleled the 2000s rise of reality television and online selfexposure. Students do not shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression. The student speech case involved an alaska high school senior who raised a banner reading, bong hits 4 jesus, at a schoolsanctioned event outside campus.
Abernathy2e full ppt04 civil liberties fall 2019 professor. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus case fox news. The case started in 2002, when the juneaudouglas high school in alaska let students cross the street to watch the olympic torch pass on its way to. The principal suspended the teenager, and the teen sued the principal for violating his first amendment rights. The 1 st amendment does not prevent a school district from disciplining a student for using speech that is lewd or indecent. As scores of curious students milled in and around the. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus case justices show no clear consensus on free speech vs. Supreme court rules to limit student speech national. Penny starr a large bong hits 4 jesus banner, which led to a 2007 supreme court decision that said such language was not protected free speech under the first amendment when displayed at a public school event, is now on prominent display at the newseum in. Bong hits 4 jesus, which she regarded as promoting illegal drug use.
Supreme court limits student speech politics nbc news. Washington the supreme court tightened limits on student speech monday, ruling against a high school student and his 14footlong bong hits 4 jesus banner. The first amendment permits schools to ban students from showing messages promoting the use of illegal drugs at school events. It is the responsibility of the school to prohibit the use of vulgarity, and to teach students about the boundaries of appropriate behavior.
Frederick sued, claiming his constitutional rights to free speech were violated. The first, as you will see later in this chapter, is the 1833 supreme court decision that the bill of rights restricted only the federal government. Justia us law us case law us supreme court volume 551 morse v. At a schoolsupervised event, joseph frederick held up a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus, a slang reference to marijuana smoking.
Frederick, also known as the bong hits 4 jesus case. The morse court relied on three supreme court student speech cases. They will be responsible for reading information related to the bong hits for jesus case. Morse believed his bong hits 4 jesus banner was a prodrug message that schools should not tolerate. We the students is a highly acclaimed resource that has introduced thousands of students to the field of legal studies by covering supreme court issues that directly affect them. Student in supreme court free speech case speaks about. It is in morse that ross analytical skills are most fully on display. On march 19, the supreme court heard oral argument in morse v. Frederick holds up bong hits 4 jesus banner,suspended by principal morse for promoting illegal drugs frederick sues for violation of his 1st amendment right q. Joseph frederick was 18 when he unveiled the 14foot paper sign on a public sidewalk outside his juneau, alaska, high school in 2002. After another high school student was suspended for refusing to take down a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus at a school event, he sued. Below, weve collected commentary on how this landmark case the first time the court has weighed students free speech rights in over 20 years could effect free speech in the future. It may involve student messages that are much more profound and are really aimed at some of the most important disputes in society.
Student loses bong hits free speech case, 2007 newseumed. The case pits a high school principals claim to broad censorship authority against a student s first amendment rights. The dissent conceded that the principal should have had immunity from the lawsuit, but argued that the majority opinion was deaf to the constitutional imperative to permit unfettered debate, even among highschool students. Ruling in bong hits case seen as leaving protection for. But only if god promised i would grow up to be a justice on the supreme court. Frederickbetter known as the bong hits 4 jesus case.
Tinker draws praise as the landmark decision on student. The court also ruled that to limit such speech was a violation of fredericks constitutional rights. In bong hits 4 jesus case, roberts says advocacy of drug use can be curbed. Justice souter remarked that bong hits 4 jesus sounds like just a kids provocative. Frederick is the high courts first student speech case in nearly 20 years, and comes at a time when school administrators and students regularly battle over religious activities in public schools. Supreme court heard arguments monday march 19 in the bong hits 4 jesus case, a free speech conflict that has caught the attention of religious litigators nationwide. Court rules against student in bong hits case anchorage. The only limits on state governments with regards to free speech, a free press, and religious freedom were those found in state constitutions. School principal deborah morse tore down the banner and suspended frederick for 10 days, saying that the banner violated the schools antidrug policy. Frederick 2007 summary the decision in one of the most important student speech cases to reach the court in decades came at the end of last term.
The bong hits 4 jesus banner did not explicitly promote illegal drug use. And in a student free speech case in which the message was perceived as promoting drug use the bong hits 4 jesus banner decision in morse v. Des moines independent school district and joe frederick of the bong hits 4 jesus case, morse v. The olympic torch passed through juneau, alaska, on january 24, 2002, on its way to salt lake city, where the winter games were to be held. Guests talked about court cases over students free speech rights. In 2002, students at schools in juneau, alaska were let out of school to watch the olympic torch be carried through town on its way to salt lake city. The court said the phrase bong hits 4 jesus reasonably could be viewed as promoting. Frederick bong hits 4 jesus case said limitations on symbolic speech can be placed on students if it is for the safety of the students drugs, gang material, etc. Justice breyer worries about people testing limits all over the place in the high schools. Frederick led a group of students who hoisted a large, nonsensical banner reading bong hits 4 jesus as the parade passed by. His principal didnt like what his mission seemed to say and suspended the then 18 year old. Aug 17, 2011 there, the student at issue, joseph frederick, held up a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus, which school officials found objectionable, during a school field trip that involved students simply standing on a public street to witness the passing of the olympic torch. Your 1st amendment rights judicial learning center.
This case is particularly eyeopening in that the offense occurred off school grounds. Mc 401 test 2 mass communication 401 with bragg at. New supreme court case excerpts cover strip searches at school, student free speech on the internet, affirmative action, the use of race in school admissions, student protest or religious speech, and the constitutional implications surrounding trends such as home schooling and rising gun violence in americas schools. And as the olympic parade neared, he and his friends unfurled a banner that read bong hits 4 jesus. This case is about limits on student speech in public schools and whether a school can punish a student for what he said about drugs during an offcampus event. Frederick, concerned the rights of a public school student to unfurl a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus.
Fraser permits school officials to limit student speech containing. Supreme court ruled against an alaska high school student suspended in 2002 for unfurling a 14foot banner bearing the words bong hits 4 jesus during a. In a case involving a juneau, alaska, high school student suspended for unfurling a banner that read bong hits 4 jesus, several justices seemed wary about giving a principal too much. As the torch is approaching, a student who was absent from the days earlier classes shows up across the street. Some students have chosen to watch the relay from the sidewalk across the street from the school. Dec, 2018 7 things you should know about free speech in schools. Held that school administrators could prevent or punish student speech that could reasonably be understood as encouraging illegal drug use. June 28, 2007 bong hits 4 jesus final episode by daniel henninger. Bong hits 4 jesus case limits student rights moments in time. Frederick the supreme court ruled this week that school principal deborah morse did not violate joseph fredericks first amendment rights. Youth teen writers offer their opinions on the supreme courts decision to limit free speech for students in the bong hits 4 jesus case. Can schools prohibit students from prohibiting illegal drug use. In this case, a high school student held up a sign reading bong hits 4 jesus across from the school during the 2002 olympic torch relay.
Mar 19, 2007 justices hear bong hits freespeech case the supreme court reexamines the rights of students to exercise free speech in school. Supreme court rules against student in bong hits 4 jesus. When will the european union order twitter to silence. Bong hits 4 jesus case at the supreme court updated 6. The student who had unfurled the banner, joseph frederick, sued for violation of his first amendment rights. Supreme court ruled against an alaska high school student suspended in 2002 for unfurling a 14foot banner bearing the words bong hits 4 jesus. It found that frederick message was, by his own admission, not political, as was the case in tinker. Supreme court said that the school could limit the students speech because it advocated illegal drug use and did not include any serious comment on social or political issues.
In a feisty session over a student s bong hits 4 jesus banner, former independent counsel kenneth starr urged the supreme court monday to let public schools ban signs, buttons or other messages that undercut their antidrug policy. Joseph frederick p, a public school student, was suspended by the principal deborah morse d for displaying a banner on which was written bong hits 4 jesus, bong being slang for marijuana, at a school event which was covered by television. The supreme court ruled against a former high school student monday in the bong hits 4 jesus banner case a split decision that limits students free speech rights. Professor james foster talks about his book, bong hits 4 jesus. Biskupic, was worded too vaguely and could include clothing that had slogans which werent disruptive in schools. Bong hits 4 jesus and the first amendment case study. Sep 15, 2009 students in public schools, for example, have freespeech rights, but they are not the same rights as what adults have in the community.
Federal court upholds college punishment for offcampus. Frederick was standing on a public street as the tv cameras came into range. Bong hits 4 jesus case tests the limits of free speech. He goes on to discuss the raging freespeech controversies in public schools today, including dress codes and uniforms, cyberbullying, and the regulation of any violentthemed expression in a postcolumbine and virginia tech environment.
Apr 29, 2020 download 4 page term paper on freedom of speech morse v. But as even the chief acknowledges, it is far from clear whether bong hits 4 jesus is a prodrug message or just a bunch of nonsense, an ambiguity that puts the courts reasoning on shaky ground. In the morse case, a student held up a sign that said bong hits 4 jesus at a schoolsupervised parade and was subsequently suspended for 10 days. Similarly, the pto disapproved registration for the mark bong hits 4 jesus because it suggests that people should engage in an illegal activity in connection with worship and because christians would be morally outraged by a statement that connects jesus christ with illegal drug use. In 2002, joseph frederick, then an 18yearold senior in juneau alaska, along with several other students held the 14foot banner that read, bong hits 4 jesus. The supreme court monday debated the case of a high school principal who suspended a student over a bong hits 4 jesus, banner displayed at a schoolsponsored event. Principal deborah morse took away the banner and suspended frederick for ten days. Each group will vote and then will write a majority opinion the ruling of the whole court, dissenting opinion the ruling of the people who disagreed with the majority, and a concurring opinion reason as to why you agreed.
672 641 509 54 250 1107 563 781 845 340 1130 393 628 754 1214 679 367 631 496 240 972 1374 1015 737 1011 1051 641 1135 713 79 822